IT Support Comparison

Managed IT Support vs Break-Fix: What's the Difference?

Break-fix IT sounds cheaper on paper. But for most businesses, the hidden costs — downtime, breaches, lost productivity — make it far more expensive in reality. Here is the straight comparison.

Side-by-side comparison

A straight look at how the two models stack up across the things that matter most.

Feature
Managed IT Support
Break-Fix IT
Monthly cost
Fixed, predictable fee per user or device
Unpredictable — you only pay when something breaks
Response time
Guaranteed SLA — critical issues under 15 minutes
No SLA — wait times vary, often hours or days
Proactive monitoring
24/7 monitoring catches issues before they cause downtime
None — problems are only fixed after they happen
Cyber security
Included: patching, threat detection, Cyber Essentials support
Not included — you are responsible for your own security
Budgeting
Easy to budget — one fixed monthly invoice
Difficult — unexpected bills can run into thousands
Relationship
Dedicated account manager who knows your business
No relationship — different engineer every call
Backups & DR
Automated backups, tested recovery procedures included
Your responsibility — often overlooked until too late
Software updates
Managed and scheduled to avoid disruption
Ad hoc — often skipped, leaving systems vulnerable
Commitment
Ongoing contract — usually 12-36 months
No commitment — use as and when needed
Upfront cost
Onboarding fee may apply
Zero — pay only when you need help

What does IT downtime actually cost you?

Based on average UK salaries of £30,000 per year (£75/hr per employee), here is what a single outage costs at different business sizes.

5 employees
£375per hour
£3,000 per day
10 employees
£750per hour
£6,000 per day
25 employees
£1,875per hour
£15,000 per day
50 employees
£3,750per hour
£30,000 per day

Estimates based on average UK salary of £30,000/year. Actual costs vary by sector, billable rates, and nature of the outage.

Which model is right for your business?

Use these scenarios to help decide.

You have 5+ employees relying on IT

Managed IT

At this scale, downtime costs more than a managed contract. One outage can cost more than months of support fees.

You store or process customer data

Managed IT

GDPR obligations make proactive security and backups essential. Break-fix leaves you exposed.

Your business operates outside 9-5

Managed IT

Break-fix engineers typically work office hours. Managed support covers you around the clock.

IT downtime directly impacts revenue

Managed IT

If your team cannot work, you are losing money. A predictable monthly fee is far cheaper than lost productivity.

You are a sole trader with minimal IT

Break-Fix

If you have one device and basic needs, occasional ad hoc support may be sufficient.

You have in-house IT expertise

Break-Fix

If you have dedicated IT staff, you may only need specialist help for specific projects.

Ready to move to managed IT support?

We offer a smooth, no-downtime switch from break-fix or your current provider. Most businesses see a return on investment within the first three months.